Nutrition Essentials: Overrated and Underrated Approaches

Avoid These Over-Hyped NutritionStrategies
By
Nick Showman
December 20, 2025
Nutrition Essentials:  Overrated and Underrated Approaches

Nick Showman

   •    

December 20, 2025

In the ever-evolving world of nutrition, certain strategies and approaches gain immense popularity, while others remain in the shadows despite their benefits. As busy adults striving for a healthier lifestyle, it's vital to discern which nutritional practices hold true value and which may be more hype than substance. In this, we'll explore some of the most overrated and underrated approaches to nutrition, empowering you to make informed decisions on your health journey.

Overrated Approaches

  1. Detox Diets
  • Detox diets promise quick results through severe calorie restriction and the avoidance of entire food groups. However, our bodies are already equipped with a natural detoxification system involving the liver, kidneys, and other organs. Instead of seeking a short-term detox, focusing on a balanced diet rich in whole foods is a more sustainable approach.
  1. Low-Carb and Keto Diets
  • While low-carb and ketogenic diets can lead to initial weight loss, they are often touted as the ultimate solution for everyone. Cutting out carbs completely isn’t sustainable for many people and can lead to nutrient deficiencies. Moderation is key; incorporating healthy carbohydrates, like whole grains and fruits, is essential for energy and overall well-being.
  1. Supplements as Quick Fixes
  • Many people rely on supplements to make up for a poor diet, believing that a quick pill can deliver all necessary nutrients. However, whole foods offer complex combinations of vitamins, minerals, and beneficial compounds in a way that supplements cannot replicate. Whole foods should be prioritized to meet nutritional needs.
  1. Meal Plans and Macro Plans
  • One of the things we don’t do at Showtime is write meal plans or provide specific macro nutrient goals. Unless you’re a robot, a specific meal plan won’t fit into your lifestyle and will likely cause more anxiety over food and social settings than fix nutritional problems. We have had success by tracking nutritional habits and making small adjustments over time and focusing on getting adequate protein intake based on goals. A general recommendation for protein is .7- 1 gram of protein per pound of bodyweight or ideal bodyweight. 

Underrated Approaches

  1. Mindful Eating
  • In our busy lives, we often consume meals on the go or while distracted, which can lead to overeating. Mindful eating is simply paying attention to the eating experience, can enhance satisfaction and help regulate portion sizes. This practice encourages being present with each bite, leading to healthier and more enjoyable meals.
  1. Vegetables and Fruit
  • Every few years, there will be a new super fruit or a supplement derived from a super fruit boasting incredible benefits. The problem is none of these have yielded bigger results than common grocery items like blueberries and green vegetables. Adults should aim for 5 daily servings of fruits and vegetables. These will help with energy and digestion while providing a ton of vitamins and minerals. Sadly, only about 11% of adults meet these basic recommendations. This is a very low hanging fruit to gain a lot of health benefit. 
  1. Cooking at Home
  • With the rise of convenience foods and takeout options, the value of home cooking is often undervalued. Cooking at home allows for better control of ingredients, portion sizes, and can foster healthier eating habits. Additionally, it can be more cost-effective and serve as a creative outlet.
  1. Diversity in the Diet
  • Many individuals tend to stick to a limited variety of foods, which can lead to nutrient deficiencies. Exploring diverse foods and cuisines can not only provide a broader spectrum of nutrients but also keep meals exciting and satisfying. Incorporating a wide array of colors and textures is beneficial.

As we navigate the complex landscape of nutrition, it’s crucial to differentiate between what truly benefits our health and what may be more temporary trends. Emphasizing mindful eating, vegetables and fruit, home cooking, and dietary diversity can lead to lasting improvements in your well-being. At the same time, being cautious of overrated approaches like detox diets and reliance on supplements can help you forge a more sustainable path toward achieving your health goals. By making informed choices based on these insights, you can cultivate a nourishing relationship with food that supports your lifestyle. When thinking about nutritional changes and evaluating them, I often think of Dan John’s quote “Little and often over the long haul”. 

Continue reading